Talk:Fish Pond - Revision history

imported>Margotbean at 16:48, 22 June 2026

2026-06-22T16:48:46Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:48, 22 June 2026
Line 123:		Line 123:
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
	::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)		::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)
			:::::Ok, I had a look through the code, and I have determined that adding the percentages is beyond what I can do right now. I've unprotected the page, so please feel free to add this info! [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 16:48, 22 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Explodingpineapple64: /* Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond */

2026-06-21T07:31:06Z

Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:31, 21 June 2026
Line 122:		Line 122:
	::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
	::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)		::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Explodingpineapple64: /* Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond */

2026-06-21T07:19:21Z

Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:19, 21 June 2026
Line 122:		Line 122:
	::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
			::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Margotbean at 14:54, 20 June 2026

2026-06-20T14:54:13Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:54, 20 June 2026
Line 120:		Line 120:
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

	I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
			:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Explodingpineapple64: /* Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond */

2026-06-19T11:50:50Z

Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:50, 19 June 2026
Line 120:		Line 120:
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

	I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this ~~ill~~ update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Explodingpineapple64: /* Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond */

2026-06-19T11:46:52Z

Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:46, 19 June 2026
Line 119:		Line 119:
	[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)		[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

			I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this ill update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Vad: /* Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary */ new section

2026-03-09T03:25:57Z

Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary: new section

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:25, 9 March 2026
Line 119:		Line 119:
	[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)		[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

			== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

			"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

imported>Vad: /* Add icons within the tables */ add comment

2026-03-09T03:23:58Z

Add icons within the tables: add comment

← Older revision		Revision as of 03:23, 9 March 2026
Line 55:		Line 55:

	: I'd support the change as well. I was actually about to create a discussion thread about it here before seeing that one was already made, lol [[User:Myirlname\|Myirlname]] ([[User talk:Myirlname\|talk]]) 10:17, 28 January 2025 (UTC)		: I'd support the change as well. I was actually about to create a discussion thread about it here before seeing that one was already made, lol [[User:Myirlname\|Myirlname]] ([[User talk:Myirlname\|talk]]) 10:17, 28 January 2025 (UTC)

			: The link to Starfarmer's discussion about the icons was lost, here it is from [[User_talk:Margotbean/Archive_2023#Fish_Pond_icons\|September 2023]].
			:: Notably, Starfarmer offered to do the "cascading" changes into other languages themself, both the icons and the proper sorting. Margotbean declined without further elaboration, although the amount of changes was given as a reason before.
			: The current table is unusable without Ctrl-F (search hotkey). Sorting is broken for English too. By default the table is not sorted at all, but "The fish appear in the same order as in the Fish Pond data file. Please keep it like that.". And if you want it sorted by Fish name? Click once on the column, it is sorted in descending order. Except that the sorted fish are first '''grouped by their requested items'''. Therefore, at the very top, sorted under letter "A" are the following fish: Albacore, Halibut, Red Mullet ... Tilapia. Yes, "T" is sorted next to A, before Anchovy (next entry).
			: Expectation? The grouping would only be possible IFF the fish names follow one another directly && required items are equal, i.e. only Red Mullet + Red Snapper. But Mediawiki cannot split such manually grouped entries, so... the sorting is actually useless given the table size. Out of 106 rows, 19 fish entries are sorted incorrectly. Emphasis: nearly 20%.
			: If there is an option to add an interactive search field as part of the table, it would be more useful than the current sorting. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:23, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

	== Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond ==		== Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond ==

imported>Vad: /* Add icons within the tables */ Fix outdated link to Margotbean's talk page

2026-03-09T01:55:18Z

Add icons within the tables: Fix outdated link to Margotbean's talk page

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:55, 9 March 2026
Line 19:		Line 19:
	So for the future, I'm pointing out the '''two last discussions''' I know about:		So for the future, I'm pointing out the '''two last discussions''' I know about:
	* [[User_talk:Charly#Fish_Pond\|November 2021 on Charly's user page]]		* [[User_talk:Charly#Fish_Pond\|November 2021 on Charly's user page]]
	* [[User_talk:Margotbean#Fish_Ponds_.7B.7Bname.7D.7D_template_changes\|January 2023 on Margotbean's user page]]		* [[User_talk:Margotbean/Archive_2023#Fish_Ponds_.7B.7Bname.7D.7D_template_changes\|January 2023 on Margotbean's user page]]

	To sum things up, there are '''two main arguments I've read''' preventing the use of the <nowiki>{{name}}</nowiki> template, but I personally do not think they stand out if dealt with properly:		To sum things up, there are '''two main arguments I've read''' preventing the use of the <nowiki>{{name}}</nowiki> template, but I personally do not think they stand out if dealt with properly:

imported>Bitterulf: /* Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond */

2026-02-23T20:15:08Z

Legend and Legend 2 on fishpond

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:15, 23 February 2026
Line 112:		Line 112:
	</syntaxhighlight>		</syntaxhighlight>
	[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)		[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)
			:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 16:48, 22 June 2026
Line 123:		Line 123:
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
	::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)		::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)
			:::::Ok, I had a look through the code, and I have determined that adding the percentages is beyond what I can do right now. I've unprotected the page, so please feel free to add this info! [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 16:48, 22 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:31, 21 June 2026
Line 122:		Line 122:
	::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
	::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)		::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data/FishPondData --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 07:19, 21 June 2026
Line 122:		Line 122:
	::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
	:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)		:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)
			::::In illspy im looking at Stardewvalley.Buildings/Fishpond/GetFishProduce(Random) and for the loot table shown by the first user in this thread is found in the game files at Stardew Valley/Content/Data --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 07:19, 21 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:54, 20 June 2026
Line 120:		Line 120:
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

	I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)		::I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this someone should update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)
			:::Hi! What is the code reference (or references) for the above analysis? [[User:Margotbean\|margotbean]] ([[User talk:Margotbean\|talk]]) 14:54, 20 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:46, 19 June 2026
Line 119:		Line 119:
	[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)		[[User:Klytos\|Klytos]] ([[User talk:Klytos\|talk]]) 16:19, 20 January 2026 (UTC)
	:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)		:I set up 10 fish ponds with the Legend and nine Legend II and wrote down for almost a year how much roe they would produce. The overall chance to produce anything was about 36 %. When they produced it was on average 1.467 roe. I got about 62.6 % of the time one roe, 29.4 % two roe, 6.6 % three roe and 1.4 % four roe. That means the description on the page can't be correct. If the pond would produce max one roe it would be about 80 % one roe, 16 % two roe and so on. The distribution I got is an almost exact overlay of an 80 % chance for one roe with the loop for additional roe and a 20 % chance for two roe with the loop for additional roe. The latest changelog states that the production was increased. So I guess the information here is not up to date. [[User:Bitterulf\|Bitterulf]] ([[User talk:Bitterulf\|talk]]) 20:15, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

			I had a browse through the code because I too was confused about this, and I've found the solution. For all legendary fish, the 'Default' legend fish will be rolled if the initial roll fails, so in the case of the Legend and Legend II, the game rolls the 50% chance to generate anything at all, then the 43% chance to generate 1 roe if that succeeds. If the 43% fails then the 50% chance for the 'Default' pool will be ran, which can have either 1 or 2 roe, then the 20% rolling chance to add roe. This creates that overlay of two distributions you talked about as if a roe is generated then after all these processes there is roughly a 80.07% one roe was generated and a 19.93% chance two were generated, then the 20% rolling chance to add to that runs. this also explains why something was generated 36% of the time rather than the supposed 21.5 (statistical value is 35.75% of the time you will get something). In light of this ill update the wiki accurately describe this process. --[[User:Explodingpineapple64\|Explodingpineapple64]] ([[User talk:Explodingpineapple64\|talk]]) 11:46, 19 June 2026 (UTC)

	== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==		== Duplicated Golden Animal Cracker explanation in summary ==

	"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)		"A Golden Animal Cracker can be thrown into the fish pond to double its output." is repeated in free flow text although just above, as a bullet point: "Golden Animal Cracker, once per Fish Pond to double the fish pond's output of its normal product". One of them should be removed, it's a duplicate. // [[User:Vad\|vad]] ([[User_talk:Vad/Talk\|talk]]) 03:25, 9 March 2026 (UTC)